FHA generally fits better when your credit is still building, you have a past credit event, or your debt ratios are higher — it allows a 3.5% minimum down payment with a 580+ score. Conventional often costs less for borrowers with strong credit, since its mortgage insurance can be removed once you build enough equity. Comparing both on your actual numbers is the only reliable way to choose.
FHA vs. conventional: side-by-side
Conventional loans aren't government-insured; most follow Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac guidelines. FHA loans are insured by the Federal Housing Administration. Here's how they generally compare:
| Feature | FHA | Conventional |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum down payment | 3.5% with a 580+ credit score; 10% with 500–579 | Low-down-payment options exist for qualified buyers (including some first-time buyer programs); larger down payments improve pricing and reduce mortgage insurance |
| Credit score | 580+ for the minimum down payment; 500–579 with 10% down; lender overlays common | Generally 620 minimum; pricing improves noticeably with higher scores |
| Mortgage insurance | Upfront MIP plus annual MIP; generally 11 years with at least 10% down, otherwise generally for the life of the loan | Private mortgage insurance (PMI) when down payment is under 20%; can generally be cancelled as equity builds and ends automatically at a scheduled point |
| Debt-to-income | Guideline 31%/43%; higher possible with compensating factors or automated approval | Automated underwriting sets limits; generally less room for high ratios |
| Credit events | Generally 2 years after Chapter 7; 3 years after foreclosure | Generally longer waiting periods |
| Property standards | FHA appraisal checks HUD minimum property standards | Appraisal focuses on value and basic condition |
| Loan limits | County-based FHA limits, often below conforming limits in lower-cost areas | Conforming limits set nationally, higher in high-cost areas; jumbo loans above |
| Occupancy | Primary residence only | Primary, second home, or investment property |
| Seller contributions | Up to 6% of the sales price | Varies by down payment and occupancy |
See FHA loan limits and FHA mortgage insurance for the details behind these rows.
FHA or conventional — which to review first?
Answer five questions to see which loan type makes sense to price out first. "Yes" answers point toward FHA; if any answer is "No," conventional may deserve an equally close look.
Is your middle credit score below the mid-600s, or are you still rebuilding credit?
Have you had a bankruptcy, foreclosure, or short sale in the last several years?
Is your total debt-to-income ratio on the higher side?
Are you putting down less than 10%?
Is the home move-in ready, with no major safety or repair issues?
Your answers stay in your browser — nothing is saved or sent. This is a quick orientation, not a loan decision.
The mortgage insurance difference
Mortgage insurance is usually the deciding factor for borrowers who could qualify for either loan.
- FHA MIP is priced the same for most borrowers regardless of credit score, which helps borrowers with lower scores. But with less than 10% down, it generally stays for the life of the loan unless you refinance.
- Conventional PMI is priced based on credit score and down payment, so it can be very affordable for strong-credit borrowers and costly for weaker ones. It can generally be removed once you reach enough equity.
Many FHA borrowers later refinance into conventional once credit and equity improve — a legitimate strategy, though it depends on future market conditions and costs.
One more nuance: FHA's upfront premium can generally be financed into the loan, while conventional PMI is usually paid monthly with no upfront charge. Some conventional lenders also offer single-premium or lender-paid options. Matthew can lay out the total mortgage insurance picture for each option over the years you expect to keep the loan.
Want a straight answer for your situation? Skip the call center — Matthew will review your credit, budget, and FHA options himself.
Talk with MatthewProperty standards and competitive offers
FHA appraisers check HUD's minimum property standards — things like peeling paint in pre-1978 homes, missing handrails, or roofs near the end of their life. Required repairs may need to be done before closing. Conventional appraisals are generally less prescriptive.
In competitive markets, some sellers worry FHA appraisals will cause delays. A well-prepared pre-approval and a short note from Matthew to the listing agent can ease that concern. For homes needing real work, an FHA 203(k) renovation loan may fit — see FHA 203(k) Info.
Real-world scenarios
Credit in the low 600s, 5% saved
FHA often prices better here, and its credit tiers leave room. Conventional may still be possible but with higher PMI. Start with FHA.
Strong credit, 10%+ saved
Conventional PMI may be low and removable later. FHA's MIP would drop off after 11 years at 10% down, but conventional often wins. Compare closely, lean conventional.
Chapter 7 discharged 2½ years ago
FHA's waiting period is generally met; conventional's usually isn't yet. FHA is likely the path.
Buying a condo not on HUD's list
FHA would need single-unit approval. Conventional has its own project review but may be simpler. Check both. See FHA condo loans.
How to choose
- Know your credit score and debt ratio. These drive most of the decision.
- Decide how much you'll put down — and how much you'll keep in reserve.
- Consider the property. Investment properties and second homes are conventional territory, since FHA is for primary residences — though you can buy a 2–4 unit home with FHA and live in one unit.
- Think about how long you'll keep the loan. Short holding periods reduce the impact of MIP duration.
- Ask Matthew for a side-by-side on the same property. As a mortgage broker, he can compare options across lenders. HUD guidelines change, and lenders may add overlays — Matthew will confirm the current rules for your file.
Frequently asked questions
Is FHA or conventional better for first-time buyers?
Neither is automatically better. FHA tends to fit buyers with lower scores or higher debt ratios; conventional often fits buyers with strong credit. See FHA for first-time buyers.
Can I switch from FHA to conventional later?
Often, yes, by refinancing once your credit and equity support it. That can remove FHA mortgage insurance, depending on the new loan.
Are FHA appraisals stricter than conventional?
FHA appraisals check HUD's minimum property standards for safety, security, and soundness, so they can call for repairs a conventional appraisal might not.
Do FHA loans have lower loan limits?
In many lower-cost counties, yes. FHA limits are set by county and are often below conforming limits outside high-cost areas.
Which loan is easier to assume if I sell later?
FHA loans are generally assumable by a qualified buyer, which can be attractive when market conditions change. Most conventional loans aren't assumable. Assumption still requires the buyer to qualify and the servicer to approve.
Does the FHA or conventional decision affect my offer in a multiple-offer situation?
It can, mainly through seller perception of the appraisal and repair requirements. A strong pre-approval and clear communication from Matthew to the listing agent helps either way.
Ask Matthew about your FHA home loan
Tell Matthew a little about the property and your plans. He'll follow up by phone or email — no obligation.
Prefer to start now? Start your pre-approval · Schedule a call · (512) 952-1125
Your information goes to Matthew only — it isn't sold to lead lists. Please don't include Social Security or account numbers.